The NFL’s version of a knuckleball—unpredictable, divisive, and annoyingly effective—has become the league’s hottest controversy. Imagine a play so brutally simple that it’s like watching a diesel truck plow through a toll booth. Now, picture every defensive coordinator in the league scrambling like a Little Leaguer trying to hit Clayton Kershaw’s slider. That’s the “tush push” in a nutshell.
A rugby-inspired, crowd-roaring pile driver that’s as polarizing as pineapple on pizza. And just when you thought the debate couldn’t get spicier, Andy Reid—mastermind of Kansas City’s dynasty—dropped a take hotter than a jalapeño popper. On Sunday, at the NFL’s annual league meetings in West Palm Beach, Reid waded into the tush push ban debate like a seasoned fisherman casting a line.
“I give them credit because they’ve done a heck of a job with it,” Reid said, tipping his hat to the Eagles’ mastery of the play. But he quickly pivoted, adding, “But I would say, if it’s putting a player in a bad position, then you probably have to do something about it.” His comments were a Rorschach test: Was this genuine concern for player safety or sour grapes from a coach whose Chiefs got steamrolled by Philly’s unstoppable push in Super Bowl LIX?
Reid’s Tightrope Walk on Tush Push: Safety vs. Strategy
Reid’s stance was a diplomatic tap dance. He acknowledged the tush push’s effectiveness—Philly converted 93% of attempts last season—but stressed the need to “listen to your medical people.” Bills coach Sean McDermott doubled down, calling the play a risk due to “posture” concerns. Yet, data tells a different story.
NFL exec Troy Vincent confirmed zero tush push-related injuries in 2023. So why the sudden uproar?
The answer lies in the Eagles’ dominance. After bulldozing their way to a 40-22 Super Bowl win—fueled by Saquon Barkley’s 229 rushing yards and Jalen Hurts’ surgical pushes—rivals are scrambling for a rulebook lifeline. It’s “tough to punish a team because it’s really good at something,” Texans coach DeMeco Ryans shrugged. Meanwhile, Eagles coach Nick Sirianni fired back at critics.
#Chiefs coach Andy Reid on the “tush push” play: “It’s a heck of a play, I know that.”
Reid says more information about it such as injuries have to be evaluated.— Rob Maaddi (@RobMaaddi) February 25, 2025
He demanded loyalty from his coaching-tree disciples: “All I will say about it is [Johnathan] Gannon, [Shane] Steichen and [Kellen] Moore better vote for it. They are in the position right now because of that play. So all three, I better have those three votes right there, and the Eagles’ vote. I at least know we have four.”
The Medical Debate and Competitive Jealousy
Beneath the safety smokescreen lies a raw truth: envy. The tush push isn’t broken; it’s just perfected. Like the 2007 Patriots’ lethal hurry-up offense, Philly’s innovation exposed a league-wide skill gap. “It reeks of jealousy,” an anonymous club exec told ESPN. Even Reid admitted, “It’s a heck of a play”—a reluctant nod to the Eagles’ schematic brilliance.
Historically, the NFL banned aiding ball carriers until 2005, when pushing was greenlit due to officiating headaches. Now, the Packers’ proposal—backed by coaches who’ve been steamrolled by Philly—seeks to reverse that, arguing the play’s “force” crosses a line. But where’s the consistency? If pushing is unsafe, why allow it on kick returns or goal-line scrums?
A Vote for Football’s Soul
As owners prepare to vote Tuesday, the tush push ban has become a litmus test for the league’s ethos. Is football a game of Darwinian innovation, or will it kneecap ingenuity to soothe bruised egos? “My job is to stop that play,” Jets coach Aaron Glenn asserted, channeling the spirit of Bear Bryant.
In the end, this isn’t about neck mechanics or posture. It’s about fear. Fear of a play that’s as unstoppable as Lawrence Taylor in his prime. Fear of a team that turned a simple push into a cultural reset. As Mark Twain once quipped, “History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes.” Will the NFL let progress rhyme with tradition, or will it fade into a chorus of “what-ifs”?
Main Photo: Mark J. Rebilas – Imagn Images
The post Former Eagles Coach Stirs Chaos with Shocking Take On Tush Push Ban Fallout appeared first on Last Word on Pro Football.
